Funny Professor Quote of the Day
You are a proctalgia fugax!
Sunday, August 14, 2011
First Bad Eval
From a resident. Don't know if it counts, thankfully the attendings gave me decent (even good) evals. But here's what it said "Ella is extremely intelligent but lacks the discipline and self-motivation that it takes to succeed in the surgery clerkship. I told her to attend a pelvic exenteration and she refused, said she was "bored" and went home at 3:30 instead".
WTF? First of all, I can PROMISE no such conversation EVER took place, I NEVER went home unless dismissed (which sure the fuck was never at 3:30) and I can certainly swear on the lives of cute innocent penguins that I never "refused" to do ANYTHING let alone would I (in quotes) say I was bored to my resident.
Effing unbelievable.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hang in there, Ella! :)
ReplyDeleteTalk to the clerkship director. Chances are that they won't do anything about the bad review, but unfortunately, in my experience they all count. And that one is really really really bad.
ReplyDeleteA friend of mine got a bad review from an ObGyn resident -- no reason was given. So she asked about it. Turns out one day the resident thought my friend was trying to read her email over her shoulder (she wasn't). The resident never said anything to her, just gave her failing marks instead. The clerkship director refused to remove the resident's marks from my friend's grade, but at least my friend got to find out what happened.
I hope I don't turn into a turd like those residents when I finally become one.
And for what it's worth, my friend matched in anesthesiology at a top program. So that ob resident? Can go F herself.
ReplyDeleteWow is that a real thing even? Crazy... maybe they mixed you up with someone else?? Either way, if I were you, I'd fight it. Fight the power!
ReplyDeleteThis is exactly why the grading part of 3rd year sucks - because it's incredibly subjective. You may not do anything wrong and still may end up "rubbing someone the wrong way." Have you considered appealing this evaluation? If it stands out as a fluke (which, from what you mention, it absolutely does), then maybe bringing it up to the course director would be a good idea. Just a thought :/
ReplyDeleteWhat?! So messed up. Did that resident get you mixed up with someone else?
ReplyDeleteThat SUCKS! Maybe he (or she) confused you with someone else?
ReplyDeletewow that is so crazy!
ReplyDeleteYou definitely were confused with someone else. If the numbers are going to affect your grade enough to change your standing in the class, bring it up with a course director. If you're afraid the contents of the comment will change how people see you in the future, don't: everyone gets one bad comment. This one is such a doozy that the lack of rampant bad evals makes it clear this was a fluke.
ReplyDelete